In
the recent past, scientists abroad have discovered that significant biological
and physiological differences exist between the sexes everywhere. For example,
in the composition of bone matter, metabolism of certain drugs, experience of
pain and the rate of neurotransmitter synthesis in the brain (courtesy Society
for Women's Health Research). This makes it necessary for drugs and treatments
to be tested on men and women equally. For example, medicines given specifically
to prevent heart arrhythmias in men, can actually cause them in women!
While
the importance of incorporating these parameters in research and of including
women in clinical trials has been accepted abroad, this Sex-Based Biology, as it
is termed, has yet to gain any recognition in India. Serious efforts need to be
made to raise awareness of these issues.
Women
are not used in clinical trials for several reasons; the main one being the
stereotypical assumption that a woman's body is essentially the same as a man's,
only smaller. Dr Marianne Legato, who set up the Partnership of Gender Specific
Medicine at the University of Colombia, says, "Women and men differ in almost
every system of their body and they respond quite differently to drugs.'' Lesley
Doyal, Professor of Health and Social Care, University of Bristol, says, "What's
not good science is to treat half the population with a drug you haven't tested
on them."
Gender
prescribing is not a trend of the near future. Researchers have found that with
heart diseases, women are more likely to show symptoms like shortness of breath
and extreme fatigue rather than chest pain. Some autoimmune diseases like
multiple sclerosis affect women eight or nine times more than men. Insensitivity
to these differences could lead from misdiagnosis to lethal side-effects.
A
darker side of unethical practice is revealed by certain activist websites like
INCITE (Women of Colour Against Violence). It alerts women to the deliberate
misuse of prescription drugs in 'off-label usage' - using a drug for treating a
condition other than what it is meant for. Off-label is legal when done with the
patient's interest at heart and with his/her consent. INCITE gives instances of
misuse of Quinacrine, an anti-malarial drug being distributed in many developing
countries including India. Quinacrine is a dangerous form of chemical
sterilisation inserted in the form of a pellet during routine pelvic
examinations where it dissolves and causes serious problems. Norplant and
Depo-Provera are other forms of family planning with major side-effects, some of
them being irreversible.
Proper
testing and inclusion of women in clinical trials will definitely lead to better
identification and treatment of medical problems and therefore, to timely and
appropriate health care for all.
Did
You Know That
• Women
lack an enzyme in the stomach that breaks alcohol down, so it goes straight into
the bloodstream, whereas men start breaking it down the moment it hits the
stomach.
• Women's
stomachs empty slower than men's, this affects how quickly drugs are
absorbed.
• Women's
hearts beat faster.
• Women
have more body fat in their total body make-up, which can affect the way
fat-soluble drugs interact with their bodies.
• Women
come out of anaesthesia faster than men,
• Some
painkillers work for women but not for men.
• Women
have more side-effects with antihistamines, antibiotics, steroids and
anti-depressants.