
Chandni was enjoying a late evening snack with her friend Rupa, when Rupa
revealed that she was bisexual. It would not have been too difficult to believe
that Chandni turned cold and left hastily. But she continued to eat her snack,
as she gracefully accepted this facet of her friend. Her mind filled with
questions, she pondered over them as she went home. Confused, she gave up. But
she was glad that she had given Rupa a patient hearing and not reacted
overtly.
Conditional
attraction and love (a man-woman relationship) is considered 'normal human
behaviour'. So is bisexuality 'abnormal'? Or, are some women born with the
natural instinct to get attracted to both women and men? While these appear to
be great discussion topics for us, for some women these are secrets shut away
from the world and hidden deep inside.
It
is the most natural thing to happen to Mridula (33), a software professional,
who has been involved with men and women since the time she was a teenager. "It
did seem strange in the beginning so I was extremely cautious about how I
behaved and reacted. But I accepted it and I am happy." She also believes that
every individual is bisexual to some degree. Says S Passano, 34, "I think more
people are bisexual than they let on, because there is not much space in society
for these things, and also because people rarely allow themselves to explore the
possibilities." Tanushree R, a mass media student, strongly believes that one
needs to be mature and look beyond our pre-conditioning to explore realms of our
sexuality. However, for her, being bisexual does not mean that she is attracted
to men and women alike. She feels there are phases in life when one is attracted
more towards a particular sex.
This
brings us to an important learning: All bisexual women are not necessarily
equally attracted to the same and opposite gender. There is diverse sexual
orientation since some are equally attracted to both genders; some are attracted
more to women than men, and vice versa. Some bisexuals have hanging sexual
orientation. Mridula thought she was bisexual a year back, but now she is
confident of being a lesbian and wants to spend her life with a woman.
Adam
and Eve were the first humans in The Garden of Eden. What if it had started off
with two men or two women or a group of both men and women? Well, then in that
case bisexuality would probably have been normal. However, Geeta Kumana who
heads Aanchal Trust, a support group for bisexual and lesbian women, feels that
bisexuality is latent in every woman and that a woman cannot be sure that she is
attracted to women till she has been with one.
If
the Mars-Venus clash creates nerve tingling chemistry, then does the dynamics of
a woman-woman relationship match up to that of a man-woman relationship? For A
Singh, 54, being attracted to a man carries a different set of tensions and
conflicts. Being attracted to a woman doesn't carry these tensions. A
relationship with a woman contains a larger component of friendship and trust
and comfort. Mridula adds that physically, these relationships are more
satisfying than those with men. "I am more comfortable in expressing myself to
women." With men there is a lot of flux in the relationship. But creating
comfort in a woman-woman relationship is relatively simple. That is perhaps due
to the overlap of demands and expectations. This does not mean that these women
are not happy with men, but they are happier with women.
Mridula
derives greater satisfaction from women in bed than with men. So it is for many
other bisexual women. A probable explanation to this is dual. Firstly a woman
knows best what another woman would like and is more likely to make her
comfortable in bed too. While some women accept their sexuality, for others this
transformation creates a lot of mental turmoil. Tanushree R spent nights crying
as she was trying to come to terms with her sexual preference. "I was in the
face of an identity crisis and finally decided to meet counsellors." Tanushree
gradually accepted that she was bisexual. Tanushree says that she is open to
getting married to a man or spending her life with a woman because marriage is
about companionship.
For
women like Tanushree, displaying interest in women always has a risk attached.
If you are a bisexual woman you have to first identify who are the other women
out there who are like-minded. Tanushree R keeps her life simple by being nice
to all women. The ones who are interested respond. There are no definitive
identifying features of lesbians, per se, although there is a likelihood of
being misinterpreted so there remains an element of risk in the simple act of
identifying a potential partner. Neeti Joshi, counsellor at Aanchal Trust feels
that it works just as like in a man-woman relationship. The chemistry sets it
off and you know when a woman is interested. A risk attached though is that the
men you are still attracted to may be adversely affected by the bisexual
tendencies you display.
There
is no particular trend in terms of partners amongst bisexual women. Some are
involved only with other bisexuals while some with heterosexuals depending on
the comfort level of the other partner.
Since
the number of people whom they can converse freely with is limited, they
participate in online communities like the BiNet LA, which is an educational,
social and support organisation for bisexuals and bi-friendly people. They
organise a social at least once a month, usually on the fourth Saturday,
providing a non-threatening, comfortable atmosphere to meet other bi-folk and
make new friends. On this point, Tanushree R clarifies a commonly help
misconception that these clubs are means of finding partners or means of
satisfying carnal desires. "We meet to share our thoughts and express ourselves
since it is a gathering of like-minded people. More importantly it is to get the
community backing, since homosexuality is illegal in our country."
Bisexual
women are as capable as anyone of being in long-term relationships. Many
bisexuals are living in committed life partnerships. Mridula has been living
with her partner since years now but cannot think of getting married. "Our
country does not have laws in place for same-sex marriages and besides, my
family would be shattered." And there is Alka who has been married to a man for
years now but she knows that she is equally attracted to both.
A
closer look at these women will hopefully broaden our perspective to the
realities which have till date been hidden from our sensibility, for it is in
the absence of conventionality that our sensitivity will truly be tested.
• Same-sex
acts are punishable by death in nine countries around the world.
• The
World Health Organization removed homosexuality from its list of diseases as
late as 1991.
• Between
two per cent and five per cent of households in the US consist of same-sex
partners.
• Same-sex
partnerships are legally recognised in the Denmark, France, Hungary, Iceland,
Netherlands, Norway, Sweden.
(Source:
Amnesty Study on Violence Against Women)
Making
Sense Of It
Every
person bears a sexual identity (male/female) and a sexual preference for a male
or female. These two combine to create varying permutations and combinations of
sexual expression, all of which are within the spectrum of normality. The
naturalness of these tendencies is multi-factorial. These include
genetic/organic elements, conditioning, sexual trauma, circumstantial exposure
like long periods spent in dormitories, sexual values and sexual role models
formed in the early years of life. So, bisexual women are in a fleeting and
constant flux in terms of their sexual orientation.
It
is in the early teens that a person starts feeling uncomfortable with his/her
sexual preference. This also depends on circumstances, which vary individually.
However, some women are more accepting of their sexuality but some go through
mental turmoil and more importantly an identity crisis and it is for these
people that counselling is required.
The
issue needs to be addressed non-judgmentally and one has to help the woman make
a choice and assess the emotional discomfort that she may have to suffer in the
long run along with the social and emotional price that comes with this
decision. Parents are also involved at times and in some cases are the ones who
encourage counselling. Is she ready and equipped to bear the burden of her
decision? This question becomes extremely relevant in a society like ours.
--Dr
Anand Nadkarni, consultant psychiatrist at the Institute of Psychological Help,
Thane
Love
In Ancient Times
Prior
to the development of the concepts of the "bisexual" and the "heterosexual
woman" as distinct types of people in the late 19th century, women were defined
primarily by their familial relationships with husbands and children. Marriage
served primarily economic and procreative functions rather than emotional
functions, and women were expected to form their closest emotional bonds with
other women. Even if and when these bonds became sexual, women were not seen as
"bisexual" because of their simultaneous marriages to men, but as women because
of their familial relationships with their husbands and children.
Even
ancient Indian sculptures depict bisexuality to a great extent. Private women's
parties were supposed to be notorious for sexual activities. Amongst men it was
widely prevalent. Ancient Spartans even encouraged same-sex relationships among
their troops so long as the men also had wives and produced children, since they
thought that physical relationships between older and younger soldiers would
solidify combat loyalty. In ancient Greece, men often engaged in same-sex
relationships, yet most also had wives. Perhaps the most famous example is
Alexander the Great who had many wives, but also a sexual relationship with his
close friend Hephaestion.
The
Kama Sutra thoroughly describes all types of sexual behavior and practices
between heterosexual or first and second-gender men and women. This is by far
the major portion of the text. Within these chapters, bisexuality is
occasionally mentioned. Apparently, in Vedic times, bisexuality was considered
to be more of a variation for men and women who were so inclined, and not as a
category of the third sex. Because bisexuals engaged in the procreative act,
they did not possess the 'napumsaka' nature of the third sex and other sexually
neutral people. The Sanskrit word 'kami' indicates that such persons were
especially fond of lovemaking and that they displayed this fondness in a variety
of ways. 'Kami' includes people who are simultaneously attracted to both men and
women or who engage in homosexuality for reasons other than natural attraction.
Those who periodically switch back and forth between heterosexuality and
homosexuality are sometimes known in Sanskrit as 'paksa-sandha'.
Bisexuality
is a curious nature in that it can move back and forth, thus involving the
question of choice, which is normally not an issue with heterosexuals or
homosexuals. Heterosexuals often confuse the homosexual nature with bisexuality,
falsely considering homosexuality to be merely a "choice" or "tendency." They
are unaware that the vast majority of homosexuals, or roughly 90 per cent, have
absolutely no attraction, natural or otherwise, for members of the opposite sex.
Bisexuals themselves are often uncertain about their own sexuality, especially
during adolescence.
In
any case, bisexuals were typically accommodated within ordinary heterosexual
society but would also frequent the third-gender communities where they were
similarly welcomed. Topics discussed in the Kama Shastra pertaining to them
include: Men who visit transvestites or masseurs working as prostitutes, men in
the company of lesbians, transvestites within the king's harem, women of the
harem satisfying themselves in lieu of the king's absence, and male servants who
practise homosexuality in their youth but then later become inclined towards
women.
What
The Law Says
Section
377, Indian Penal Code states: "Whoever voluntarily has carnal intercourse
against the order of nature with any man, woman or animal shall be punished with
imprisonment for life or imprisonment of either description for a term which may
extend to 10 years and shall also be liable to fine."
There
has been no change with regard to the concept of this offence and its
administration by the Indian courts. It is considered to be an offence against
society, therefore, the legal system is obliged to punish all those who are
proved to have indulged in it.
The
concept of homosexuality as a form of co-habitation or of an enjoyable union of
two individuals has not been the defense in any of the reported matters except
in the case of two women police constables who were relieved of their service,
when their lesbian union became public.
Since
homosexual behaviour is legally a crime, organisations of homosexuals are not
permitted as legal entities or bodies. What is punishable is the act of
homosexual behaviour and not the discussion or talking about it or its
representation. It cannot be advocated under the existing laws. If done, it
would amount to abatement of the offence. It is punishable with 10 years of
imprisonment and fine. No one so far is known to have been awarded 10 years of
imprisonment for having been found guilty of this offence. In matters leading to
conviction, the maximum punishment so far reported to have been awarded is two
years.
Since
homosexuality is an offence, there cannot be a regular flow of any organised
information about it, which might further promote it. However, there is no ban
on any publication, which deals with it from a social reformative point of view.
Under
the provisions of various personal family laws prevalent and in force in India,
two persons of homosexual behaviour will not be able to inherit the assets of
each other on the grounds of their union and intimacy. If a will is made and is
challenged by any other possible beneficiary, the said testament will not hold
good in the court, as it is likely to be struck down on grounds of morality and
for being against the public policy. If not challenged, it may go
unnoticed.
There
is no legislation, which might expressly protect homosexuals except by applying
the general principles of law and order. The questions of seeking palimony or
alimony or maintenance out of homosexual relationship has never come up before
the courts. There is no provision in law for seeking such relief.
(Source:
www.ilga.info.com)
List
of organisations that can help:
Stree
Sangam
Post
Box No116619, Matunga, Mumbai-400019
Jagori
Add:
C-54 Top Floor, South Extension-II New Delhi-110049
Tel:
+91-11-2625 7015, Fax: +91-11-2625 3629
E-mail:
jagori@spectranet.com, jagori@del3.vsnl.net.in
Website:
www.jagori.org
India
Centre for Human Rights and Law
Add:
4th Floor CVOD Jain High School, Hazrat Abbas Street; 84, Samuel Street, Dongri,
Mumbai-9
E-mail:
huright@giasbm01.vsnl.net.in
Lawyers
Collective HIV/AIDS unit
Add:
7/10, Botawalla Building, 2nd Floor, Horniman Circle, Fort, Mumbai-400 023
Tel:
022 2267 6213 / 6219
Fax:
022 2270 2563
E-mail:
aidslaw@vsnl.com
Website:
www.lawyerscollective.org
OLAVA
- Organised Lesbian Alliance for Visibility and Acceptance
Add:
Post Box 2108, Model Colony Post Office,
Pune-411
016
E-mail:
olava_2000@yahoo.com
Sangini
(India) Trust
Add:
C/o Naz Foundation (India) Trust, D-45, Gulmohar Park, New Delhi-110 049
Tel:
011 2656 3929 / 7049, 0 98106 71603
Fax:
011 2685 9113
E-mail:
sangini97@hotmail.com/ sanginigroup@hotmail.com
Website:
www.sangini.org
Sappho
Add:
C/o A N, PO Box No EC-35, Kolkata, Pin 700 010
Tel:
033 2281 3462 (Mondays 1-3 pm)
E-mail:
sappho1999@rediffmail.com
Swikriti
Tel:
0 98301 82419
E-mail:
swikriti2003@hotmail.com
Prerana
E-mail:
sahayabangalore@hotmail.com
Sangama
Add:
Flat No 13, 3rd Floor, Royal Park Apartment, 34 Park Road, Tasker Town,
Bangalore-560 051
Tel:
080 286 8680/ 8121
E-mail:
sangama@vsnl.net/ sangama@sangamaonline.org
Aanchal
Trust
Add:
Tardeo AC Market Building, 3rd Floor, Room No 28, Tardeo, Mumbai-400 034
Tel:
022 2496 8686/ 8787
E-mail:
aanchal69@hotmail.com
Samabhavana
Society
Add:
602, Debonair, 153 BVS Marg, Mahim, Mumbai-400 016
Tel:
022 2446 7543
E-mail:
samabhav@vsnl.com
Website:
www.samabhavana.org
|